Ministry of Health clarifies proposal to allow people under 18 years old to donate tissues and organs

(Chinhphu.vn) - Regarding public concerns about seeking consent from children under 18 years old when registering to donate tissues or human body parts, the Ministry of Health stated that the draft Law on Donation, Removal, and Transplantation of Human Tissues and Body Parts and Donation and Removal of Cadavers (amended) does not encourage donation in children but aims to establish a strict legal framework, ensuring the safety and rights of children, and creating a basis for considering appropriate donation cases that current laws do not regulate.

The Law on Donation, Acquisition, and Transplantation of Human Tissues and Body Parts and Donation and Acquisition of Remains (amended) is being submitted to the National Assembly for consideration and opinion at the 2 session, XVI National Assembly.

Discouraging tissue and organ donation in children 

In response to diverse opinions on the proposal to allow individuals under 18 years old to register for tissue and body part donation, on 23/10, the Ministry of Health provided information to clarify the contents of the draft law, donation conditions, and measures to protect children.

The Department of Medical Examination and Treatment Management, Ministry of Health - the unit presiding over the drafting process, stated that with the consistent principle of ensuring the best interests of the child, the draft Law aims to create more treatment opportunities for children with life-threatening illnesses, especially in cases where tissues and body parts of a specific size and anatomical characteristics are required, which supply from adults is difficult to meet.

At the same time, this regulation respects the wishes of those under 18 years old and their families to donate, including the desire to donate after death so that life can continue in other patients.

The Ministry of Health emphasizes that the draft does not encourage the donation of tissues or organs from children, but aims to establish a strict legal framework, ensuring the safety and rights of the child, creating a basis for considering suitable donation cases that current laws do not yet regulate.

For those under 18 years old, the draft Law clearly distinguishes between donation while alive and donation after death. These are two fundamentally different cases.

Firstly, while alive: those under 18 years old can only donate regenerative tissues (such as hematopoietic stem cells) to treat relatives when there is no suitable adult donor. Those from 15 to under 18 years old donate to family members; those under 15 years old only donate to parents, siblings.

Children must be in good health, receive independent counseling, and have the consent of both the child and their parents or guardians. The draft Law continues to strictly prohibit the removal of kidneys, liver, heart, lungs, or any other healthy body part from a living person under 18 years old.

Second, after passing away: The removal of tissues or body parts is only considered when the child has been determined to be brain dead or circulatory dead by an independent professional council, has registered or expressed a wish to donate before passing away, and has obtained the consent of their parents or guardians.

Individuals under 18 years old may register to donate when they have written consent from their parents or guardians; they may change or cancel their registration at any time.

From the practical perspective of a doctor, Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nguyen Lan Hieu, Director of Hanoi Medical University Hospital, said he has encountered many children with end-stage heart and kidney failure waiting for transplants. Many could not wait for a suitable organ, partly because current laws do not allow those under 18 years old to register to donate after death. Meanwhile, transplanting adult organs into small children faces many difficulties due to differences in organ and vessel size.

This expert also expressed the view that young people, especially children, need to be provided with age-appropriate information and be allowed to express their opinions without pressure. However, while listening to children, one should not absolutize their opinions while ignoring their age and educational background.

"Listening to children does not mean forcing them to bear a decision beyond their capacity; but protecting them does not mean stripping them of their right to speak. Expanding the source of organs to save small children is necessary... The humanity of the policy lies not only in the number of children saved, but also in how we ensure the dignity and best interests of each child," Assoc. Prof. Nguyen Lan Hieu shared.

Practical experience in the country and internationally regarding tissue and organ donation in children 

Practical experience and international practice also show that from the first organ transplant performed in 1992 to 3 2026, our country has performed a total of 11.187 human organ transplant cases.

The number of children suffering from organ and tissue failure who need transplants is very large (at the National Children's Hospital, there are more than 20 patients waiting for liver transplants annually, and about 40 patients waiting for kidney transplants; at the Children's Hospital 2, in the year 2022, there were more than 80 pediatric patients with end-stage chronic kidney failure). If individuals under 18 years old who have suffered brain death or circulatory death donate their tissues or body parts, it will provide a life-saving opportunity for many children.

According to the guiding principles of the World Health Organization (WHO), the harvesting of cells, tissues, or organs from a living minor is only performed in exceptional cases, under strict protection conditions. The Oviedo Convention of the Council of Europe also allows for the donation of regenerative tissues to treat siblings under strict conditions.

Regarding organ donation after death, data from the Council of Europe for the year 2023 indicates that many countries such as the United States, United Kingdom, Germany, Australia, Italy, Thailand, and Malaysia have implemented this for people under 18 years old.

The Ministry of Health states that these are the bases for the drafting committee to consult, research, and evaluate the suitability for the practical conditions of Vietnam, ensuring the necessary legal framework and protection mechanisms.

Control mechanisms to prevent the trading of tissues and organs and protect children

Addressing concerns on social media regarding the risk of trading human tissues and body parts, including those of children, the Drafting Committee emphasized that this draft strictly prohibits trading, coercion, theft, brokerage of human tissues and body parts, and taking advantage of guardianship, alternative care, or adoption relationships to obtain tissues and body parts from children; violators can be criminally prosecuted according to regulations.

At the same time, the transplant must be coordinated through a national code and a fair waiting list; living donors must have their identity verified and be evaluated by an independent advisory council.

The process of determining brain death or circulatory death is ensured to be independent and objective, preventing conflicts of interest and behaviors that falsify results. At the same time, the Ministry of Health also requests citizens to immediately notify the police or competent authorities upon discovering signs of brokerage or trading of human tissues or organs.

Currently, the draft Law is continuing to receive feedback from National Assembly delegates and the public, in order to be revised and completed in a strict and humane manner, bringing life opportunities to patients and best protecting the rights and interests of children.

Hien Minh


Source: https://baochinhphu.vn/bo-y-te-lam-ro-de-xuat-cho-phep-nguoi-duoi-18-tuoi-hien-mo-tang-102261023132305124.htm


Share: