Tax policy must be targeted correctly and bring substantive benefits

National Assembly deputies participate in discussions and contribute opinions at the Group level on the projects: State Budget Law (consolidated); Project to amend and supplement a number of articles of the Corporate Income Tax Law, Non-Agricultural Land Use Tax Law, and Personal Income Tax Law

On the afternoon of 23/10, continuing the 2rd Session, the XVI National Assembly, delegates discussed at the group level about the State Budget Law project (consolidated) and the project of the Law on amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Corporate Income Tax Law, the Non-agricultural Land Use Tax Law, and the Personal Income Tax Law.

Participating in the discussion at Group 3, including the National Assembly delegations of Hai Phong, Lang Son, and Ha Tinh, were Prime Minister Le Minh Hung and Permanent Deputy Prime Minister Pham Gia Tuc.

The opinions agreed on the necessity of amending tax laws to institutionalize the policy of developing education and training, supporting citizens, and using land resources effectively; at the same time, suggested carefully assessing budget impacts, clearly defining the scope of incentives and implementation conditions.

Non-profit operation does not mean no surplus of revenue over expenditure

Delegate Nguyen Thi Viet Nga, Deputy Head of the Hai Phong National Assembly Delegation, assessed that the draft law has few amended articles but significant impact on budget revenue, the investment environment, and the obligations of citizens and businesses. According to the delegate, each policy should be viewed from three perspectives: Is it on target, who receives the actual benefits, and is there sufficient capacity for implementation?

With the proposal to exempt tax for educational institutions, the delegate supported creating more favorable conditions for public institutions and non-profit private institutions, in order to mobilize resources, improve training quality, and expand learning opportunities.

According to the delegates, the draft has added provisions to identify educational institutions according to the laws on education, vocational education, and higher education. However, it is necessary to ensure that institutions benefiting from incentives maintain their non-profit nature throughout the period the policy is applied.

The delegate noted that educational institutions may not distribute profits directly but still transfer benefits to investors through property rent, loan interest, management fees, or transactions with related parties at prices not appropriate to market reality. Therefore, it is necessary to stipulate principles of transparency, determine reasonable costs, and control these transactions, not to restrict legitimate and necessary transactions but to prevent the diversion of resources earmarked for education to private interests.

On the other hand, non-profit operation does not mean having no surplus of revenue over expenditure. Educational institutions still need to accumulate funds to upgrade facilities, improve staff income, and develop activities. High tuition is also not the sole basis for concluding that an institution operates for profit. The decisive factor is how resources are used, reinvested, and whether they are distributed in violation of regulations.

Therefore, the delegate suggested that the law clearly define the scope of exempt income, conditions for maintaining incentives, and principles for handling cases when institutions no longer meet the conditions; empowering the Government to specify implementation methods. It is necessary to distinguish income from education, research, and support activities from income from independent commercial business, to avoid the understanding that all revenues of educational institutions are tax-exempt.

Regarding retrospective collection, the delegate suggests distinguishing between cases of deceit regarding conditions from the beginning and cases of subsequent partial misuse of income, ensuring proportionate handling, both protecting the budget and creating stability for law-abiding establishments.

According to the project documents cited by the delegate, the policy is expected to reduce corporate income tax revenue in the education sector by about 2.200 billion VND per year. The delegate suggested clarifying the calculation basis, the number of facilities truly eligible, and the additional tax reduction compared to current incentives; and simultaneously monitoring the use of tax-exempt resources for training quality, scholarships, and learner support.

Sharing the same view, delegate Doan Thu Ha (Lang Son delegation) basically agrees with the proposal to exempt taxes for educational institutions, while suggesting clarification of the criteria for determining non-profit private educational institutions, controlling transactions with related parties, and establishing tax handling principles when institutions no longer meet the eligibility criteria for incentives.

Regarding the proposal to exempt income tax for organizations and individuals providing meals at schools and medical examination and treatment facilities, delegate Nguyen Thi Viet Nga agrees with the goal of supporting students and patients but suggests clarifying the mechanism for transferring benefits from providers to users.

According to the delegate, if the contract price remains the same, the tax portion exempted may only increase the benefits for the supplier without helping to reduce costs for the user. For entities that do not have taxable income, the support effect may also be limited.

The tax exemption also does not ensure that meals are improved in terms of nutrition, quality, and food safety. Therefore, the delegate suggested assessing the impact of the policy, especially by comparing it with the plan to directly support meals for those who need it, in order to identify a more effective, targeted, and measurable plan for budget use.

If continuing the policy, delegates suggested clarifying the beneficiaries of meal allowances, the scope of contracts, methods for separating tax-exempt revenue; linking incentives with price transparency, quality, and the timing of effectiveness re-evaluation. At the same time, there is a need to justify the scope of incentives in relation to groups with similar support needs.

The delegate also noted that the provisions on exceptions in clause 1 of Article 18 related to clause 5b of Article 15 must be clarified, to avoid any interpretation that tax exemption is synonymous with exemption from invoice and documentation obligations. Regardless of the tax calculation method applied, there must be grounds to determine exempted activities and trace food sources.

According to the delegate, before deciding on indefinite tax exemption for meal providers, there needs to be persuasive evidence regarding the actual benefits for learners and patients.

Tax on abandoned land: Do not let tax payments replace land-use responsibilities

Regarding the proposal for a 0,2% tax rate, with no limit applied to abandoned land, unused land, or land for which use is delayed, delegate Nguyen Thi Viet Nga supports the use of tax tools to combat land waste, but suggests distinguishing between deliberate land hoarding or delays and cases with objective reasons or adherence to approved schedules.

Delegates noted that clause 6, Article 7 of the current Law on Non-Agricultural Land Use Tax already stipulates a 0,15% tax rate for land used for the wrong purpose, land not yet used in accordance with regulations, and separate regulations for phased investment projects. If adding a 0,2% rate without addressing the relationship with existing regulations, an area of land could be interpreted as falling under two tax rates. Therefore, it is necessary to clearly define each application case.

One issue that directly affects the people is whether legal residential land of households and individuals that has not yet been built on falls under the scope of adjustment. The delegate proposed identifying the competent authority to conclude on land use status, the starting and ending points for tax calculation, and the notification and processing procedures when the land user does not agree.

Cases of delay due to procedures of state agencies, failure to hand over land, force majeure, or approved phasing schedules must be distinguished from delays caused by the investor's fault. Tax policy also needs to be placed in relation to land use extensions, additional financial obligations, and land reclamation under land laws.

“Payment of taxes does not replace the obligation to use land for its intended purpose and does not remove the grounds for land reclamation,” the delegate emphasized, while suggesting an assessment of total financial obligations and their actual effect in promoting land use.

Delegate Nguyen Thi Viet Nga also suggested assessing the impact of adding land area in the scope of a province or city after administrative unit arrangement. Situations may arise where citizens do not buy more land but the way the area is calculated changes due to new boundaries, leading to increased tax obligations. For localities like Hai Phong, specific checks are needed to have transitional regulations and public guidance if impacts arise.

Sharing the same view on combating land waste, delegate Doan Thu Ha believes that regulations on abandoned land must be strictly compared with the draft Land Law (amended) currently under review. According to the delegate, the three concepts of “abandoned land”, “unused land”, and “delayed use of land” have not been clearly clarified. Land laws define violations and grounds for reclamation, but there is no common definition of “abandoned land”, so general references can easily lead to different interpretations.

The delegate suggested adding the phrase "and detailed regulations by the Government" to the regulations on land left abandoned, not put into use, or slow to be put into use, to have a basis for concretizing during implementation.

At the same time, it is necessary to stipulate a uniform starting point for calculating the 0,2% tax rate: from the date of land non-use, the expiration date for putting the land into use, or the date the competent authority determines the land status. Land management agencies need to be responsible for determining and providing information on the legal status, area, and duration of non-use or delayed progress to the tax authority as a basis for tax calculation.

Delegate Doan Thu Ha also suggested having a clear handling method for land issues involving site clearance, administrative procedures, planning adjustments, disputes, or force majeure; to avoid imposing high tax rates on cases not caused by the fault of the land user.

In addition, it is necessary to quantify the tax rate of 0,2% based on the taxable land price to evaluate the ability to promote land utilization. Tax collection must be linked to handling violations and land recovery according to regulations, without creating a mentality that just paying additional tax is enough to continue holding land for a long time.

Regarding the policy on non-agricultural land use tax exemption, Delegate Doan Thu Ha proposed adding Clause 12 of Article 9, stipulating tax exemption for households that have a small annual tax payment amount as prescribed by the Government. This is a proposal to add to the tax exemption cases already existing in the draft submitted to the National Assembly.

Delegates suggested fully assessing the impact on local budgets, completing transitional regulations, and preparing guidance documents before the law takes effect. According to delegate Nguyen Thi Viet Nga, tax policy needs to create momentum for development, nurture sustainable revenue sources; incentives must reach the right places that need encouragement, and obligations must be clear, commensurate, and harmonize the interests of the State, citizens, and businesses.

Diep Anh


Source: https://baochinhphu.vn/chinh-sach-thue-phai-dung-doi-tuong-mang-lai-loi-ich-thuc-chat-102261023174806472.htm


Share: