Tightening post-inspection, clarifying food safety management responsibilities

Discussing the draft Law on Food Safety (amended), National Assembly delegates suggested strengthening post-inspection based on risk levels, perfecting mechanisms for data management, advertising, food recalls, and clearly defining the responsibilities of relevant agencies.

Tightening post-audit, clarifying food safety management responsibilities - Photo 1.

Panorama of the Group 3 discussion session on the afternoon of 24/10 - Photo: chinhphu.vn/Nhat Bac

On the afternoon of 24/10, the National Assembly held group discussions on the draft Law on Cultural Industry Development; the draft Law on Food Safety (amended); and the draft Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Intellectual Property.

Attending the group discussion session 3 were National Assembly deputies (NADs) from the National Assembly Deputy Delegations of Hai Phong City, Ha Tinh Province, and Lang Son Province. Politburo member and Prime Minister Le Minh Hung; Politburo member and Permanent Deputy Prime Minister Pham Gia Tuc attended the discussion session.

Enhancing post-audit, managing by risk level

Contributing opinions to the draft Law on Food Safety (amended), delegate Pham Thu Xanh (Hai Phong City) agreed with the necessity of amending the Law, and proposed to continue perfecting the regulations to overcome shortcomings in management practice.

Delegates pointed out 6 "loopholes" in management, including: The self-declaration mechanism can be abused; post-audit is not strong enough for early detection; responsibilities among ministries and sectors remain scattered; misleading advertising on digital platforms is hard to control; risks of unsafety in collective kitchens; and uneven testing capacity, data infrastructure, and grassroots human resources.

Delegates proposed amending Article 57 to clearly stipulate periodic sampling plans by risk group; unscheduled post-inspection upon warnings or signs of violations; processing deadlines and public disclosure of results upon conclusion. Well-compliant facilities may have their inspection frequency reduced, while high-risk, recidivist, or warned products must be subject to enhanced inspection, which does not equate to exemption from post-inspection.

Regarding the case of nearly 600 types (573 labels) of fake milk powder produced and publicly consumed by Rance Pharma and Hacofood Group for about 4 years, the delegate argued that the self-declaration mechanism under Decree No. 15/2018/ND-CP has been exploited, while post-inspection has not kept pace.

With Article 58, it is necessary to stipulate sanctions commensurate with the degree of harm, illicit profits, recidivism, and consequences; ensure recall, consumer warning, and public disclosure of violations when there are sufficient legal grounds.

Regarding product classification, delegates proposed reviewing Article 46 and Appendix number 1, unifying criteria based on hazard level, target users, traceability capability, and violation history. It is necessary to maintain controlled registration for medical nutritional foods, products for young children, and health-recommendation groups; and to simplify procedures for the low-risk group through an electronic, one-stop mechanism and clear processing timelines. Delegates also proposed a mechanism for hospitals to use already announced medical nutritional foods in inpatient treatment under medical indication and supervision, avoiding duplicate procedures.

Regarding food data and advertising, Articles 14, 15 and 19 need to ensure interconnected, updated databases capable of handling incidents; unify product, facility, and batch identification codes; and clearly define responsibilities and updating deadlines. For high-risk groups, a mandatory roadmap for electronic traceability from manufacturers and importers to distributors and points of sale is required.

From the case of Kera vegetable candy advertising in year 2025, delegates suggested synchronously amending Articles 13 and 61, stipulating the verification of dossier validity, tracing sellers and advertising content; promptly hiding or removing when there is basis, preserving data for processing. The responsibilities of advertisers, influencers, and e-commerce platforms must be specifically regulated, especially for health claim products and products for vulnerable groups.

Delegates proposed amending Article 57 to clearly stipulate periodic sampling plans by risk group, unscheduled post-inspection upon warnings or signs of violations, processing deadlines, and public disclosure of results upon conclusion. Well-compliant facilities may have their inspection frequency reduced, but shall not be exempted from post-inspection; high-risk, recidivist, or warned products must be subject to enhanced inspection.

Regarding Article 58, delegates suggested stipulating sanctions commensurate with the degree of harm, illicit profits, recidivism, and consequences; ensuring recall, consumer warning, and public disclosure of violations when there are sufficient legal grounds.

Regarding product classification, delegates proposed reviewing Article 46 and Appendix number 1, standardizing criteria based on hazard level, target users, traceability capability, and violation history. It is necessary to maintain controlled registration for medical nutritional foods, products for young children, and health-recommendation groups; and to simplify procedures for the low-risk group through an electronic, one-stop mechanism with clear processing timelines.

Delegates also suggested establishing a mechanism for hospitals to use published clinical nutrition food in inpatient treatment under medical indication and supervision, avoiding duplicate procedures.

Regarding data and food advertising, delegates proposed completing Articles 14, 15, and 19 to ensure that databases are interconnected, updated, and usable when incidents occur; standardizing identification codes for products, facilities, and shipments along with responsibilities and update deadlines. For high-risk groups, there must be a roadmap requiring mandatory electronic traceability from manufacturers and importers to distributors and points of sale.

Citing the case of Kera vegetable candy advertising in year 2025, delegates proposed synchronously amending Article 13 and Article 61, regulating the verification of dossier validity, seller tracking, and advertising content; timely temporarily hiding or removing upon grounds and preserving data for processing purposes. It is necessary to specifically regulate the responsibilities of advertisers, influencers, and e-commerce platforms, especially for products with health recommendations and products for vulnerable groups.

Tightening post-audit, clarifying food safety management responsibilities - Photo 2.

Delegate Pham Thu Xanh (National Assembly Deputy of Hai Phong City) contributing ideas at the group discussion session - Photo: chinhphu.vn/Nhat Bac

Regarding management responsibilities, delegates supported the provision in Article 63 designating the Ministry of Health as the unified focal point for state management of food safety. According to delegates, the Ministry needs substantive coordination power in formulating a risk-based national plan, sharing data, issuing warnings, tracing, recalling, and handling inter-sectoral incidents; and reporting to the Government when coordination is not implemented or disagreements persist.

Delegates suggested clearly defining the lead agency for each product group, facility type, and incident scenario, assigning responsibility to the heads. Article 71 needs to delineate responsibilities between provincial and communal levels while ensuring human resources, funding, and enforcement capacity to avoid evasion and shifting of responsibilities.

In addition, it is necessary to increase regional testing capacity, prioritizing areas far from the center and grassroots lines; stipulate criteria on capacity, independence, conflict of interest control, and legal liability of testing organizations.

Clarifying the scope and process of recalling unsafe food

Delegate Nguyen Hoang Tung (Lang Son province) suggested clarifying regulations on stopping the production and business of unsafe food. When there is a basis to determine unsafe food, the facility must immediately stop the production and business of related food, promptly report, and implement measures to prevent and remedy consequences. If keeping the 24-hour milestone, it is necessary to clearly define the scope of application, distinguishing the time of implementation from the time of completing remediation, without altering the reporting obligation as prescribed.

Tightening post-audit, clarifying food safety management responsibilities - Photo 3.

Delegate Nguyen Hoang Tung (Lang Son province) speaking - Photo: chinhphu.vn/Nhat Bac

Regarding the exemption of product announcement, delegates proposed uniformly amending point c of clause 2, clause 8 of Article 46 and Appendix number 1; reviewing the scope of exemption for post-processed foods in street food business, small-scale production and business, and catering services.

Exempted cases must be fully presented in the appendix, with clear cross-references and clarified relationships with the group of products requiring registration under clause 1 of Appendix 1. Delegates noted the need to distinguish procedures for each product from cases where a facility does not fall under the scope of food safety eligibility certificates; do not use the name of small-scale establishments or sales locations to replace the determination of obligations regarding products.

Regarding food recall, delegates suggested reviewing the correspondence between clause 1 and clause 3 of Article 56; clarifying the scope of recall for violations affecting food safety, quality deviations, and labeling errors. If keeping the recall basis in point h of clause 1, it is necessary to stipulate directly or cross-reference appropriately; while clarifying how to determine violating products in point b of clause 3 to identify products, batches, and related scope.

According to delegates, regulations must be specific enough for facilities to implement, management agencies to inspect, and citizens to recognize products that need to be discontinued, ensuring full recall without expanding to unrelated products.

Bich Phuong


Source: https://baochinhphu.vn/siet-chat-hau-kiem-lam-ro-trach-nhiem-quan-ly-an-toan-thuc-pham-102261024170143626.htm


Share: