Prime Minister: Whether to bid or not, the investor is the one who decides and must evaluate based on final results
(Chinhphu.vn) - On the afternoon of 23/10, the National Assembly held group discussions on the draft Law on State Budget (consolidated); the draft Law amending and supplementing a number of articles of the Law on Corporate Income Tax, the Law on Non-Agricultural Land Use Tax, the Law on Personal Income Tax; and the draft Law on Bidding (amended).
Speaking at the group discussion, Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh (National Assembly delegate of Hai Phong city) respectfully thanked the delegates for their careful study and responsible and specific contributions to improve the draft laws; the presiding agencies for drafting will study and accept these opinions.
The Prime Minister emphasized that building a consolidated State Budget Law project (based on consolidating the Public Investment Law and the State Budget Law) is extremely necessary; because matters related to the use of the state budget are currently regulated by two laws; and the implementation process also faces some obstacles and inadequacies.
Clarifying some major contents, the Prime Minister said that the draft Law has affirmed the leading role of the Central budget in accordance with the spirit of the Central and National Assembly's directives; inheriting the regulations on the decentralization of revenue sources and spending tasks between the Central and local budgets.
Regarding the four new shared revenue items: Corporate income tax, personal income tax, special consumption tax, and environmental protection tax, the sharing ratio will be submitted by the Government to the National Assembly for decision for each group of localities, with the orientation of long-term stability, consistent with the spirit of the Central Committee's conclusion.
At the same time, supplement principles when issuing policies and regimes that require full impact assessment, clearly determining resources and budget balancing capabilities at each level. This is a very important point in the draft Law to affirm the leading role of the central budget.
The Prime Minister stated that the determination this year is to increase the revenue structure ratio of the Central budget. This is the basis for the Central budget to carry out critical spending tasks in key sectors and support localities. According to the Prime Minister, even for localities that have achieved budget self-sufficiency, the Central budget must continue to support investment spending for key works and projects.
"If the leading role of the Central budget is not ensured, the Government and the National Assembly cannot manage socio-economic development goals, ensuring national defense and security," the Prime Minister stated.
Along with that, resources for the commune level in the draft Law are suitable for the two-level administration, ensuring decentralization and delegation associated with resources and accountability. The draft Law has inherited the regulations assigning the Provincial People's Council to decide on the decentralization of revenue sources, spending tasks, and revenue sharing ratios; while also adding some general principles according to the spirit of the Central Committee's conclusions.
The spirit is to promote decentralization and delegation of power linked with resource allocation and resolutely put an end to the situation of assigning tasks without ensuring implementation conditions; at the same time, there must be a mechanism for budget allocation, increasing the appropriate revenue retention rate for the commune level, ensuring the local level has enough conditions to operate, serve the people, and organize socio-economic development in the area.
Emphasizing that this content is very important, the responsibility of ward and commune-level authorities is very high, and work requirements are also very high, the Prime Minister hopes that National Assembly delegates in localities will carefully study the regulations related to budget decentralization for the commune level. The general responsibility for allocated resources belongs to the Provincial People's Council, but the law must have framework regulations.
Another very important point according to Conclusion No. 18 of the 2th Central Committee Plenum is the need to account for socio-economic efficiency in public investment. According to the Prime Minister, if we want to reduce the ICOR, besides accelerating progress and shortening implementation procedures, we must also reduce the number of projects.
The Prime Minister informed that in the last term, there were about 5.000 public investment projects nationwide, which is a sharp decrease compared to previous terms, but this term must further reduce the number of projects by at least 30%. From there, concentrate resources on projects with spillover effects; poverty reduction, support for ethnic minorities, difficult areas; ensuring defense, security, and sectors such as health, education, and culture.
The Prime Minister stated that evaluating the effectiveness of a project is not just about economic efficiency, but overall socio-economic efficiency and issues related to ensuring national defense, security, improving infrastructure capacity, and the level of improvement in living standards and social welfare that people enjoy. At the same time, investment effectiveness must be evaluated throughout the entire project lifecycle, from planning, appraisal, approval, to implementation and post-investment operation and exploitation.
The draft also clearly specifies the responsibilities of each subject involved in the decision-making and implementation process of public investment projects, such as the Government's responsibility to regulate the process of evaluating investment efficiency; the responsibility of ministries and central agencies to issue and guide criteria for evaluating investment efficiency in their assigned sectors; heads of budget estimation units must perform investment efficiency evaluation in proposing allocation, management, and use of public investment state budget; as well as defining how program owners and investors are responsible. This is a very new point in the draft Law.
Referring to the science and technology sector with many specific characteristics and many new issues emerging, the Prime Minister gave examples such as investment in strategic technology products, investment in digital infrastructure and digital transformation, and digitization which require solid and thorough appraisal. Therefore, the responsibility for allocation still lies with the finance agency, but at the same time, it is necessary to stipulate the responsibility of the Ministry of Science and Technology in general appraisal in terms of professional expertise, ensuring compliance with the requirements for scientific and technological development.
On the other hand, the Government must also rely on experts and specialized agencies to assist in verifying expenditure contents. The Prime Minister stated that the Government and localities are very cautious in investing in science, technology, and digital transformation infrastructure, based on the need for a synchronous overall framework design; without careful and thorough work, it will be wasteful.
Regarding simplifying processes and procedures, the draft Law also amends regulations on establishing, allocating, and assigning capital in the direction of integrating the processes of planning and allocating development investment and recurrent expenditure in the 5-year financial plan and annual estimates; and specifies which cases do not require investment policy approval.
For group C projects, which account for over 60% of the total number of projects in the phase, have small scale and short investment duration, they will not carry out investment policy approval but will integrate some contents into the approval step of the policy and the approval step of the investment decision.
For group A and B projects, especially national priority projects with large investment capital scales and long implementation periods, it is necessary to have an investment policy approval step as suggested by the National Assembly delegates.
The Prime Minister stated that the Government will also continue to review to simplify administrative procedures, improve implementation, but most importantly, it must ensure the effectiveness and goals of the investment. At the same time, continue to direct the Ministry of Finance to perfect relevant decrees and circulars to be effective in a timely and synchronous manner with the draft Law.
Regarding the content that delegates are interested in concerning the regulation of annual source transfer, the Prime Minister affirmed that this must have very specific regulations to tighten financial and budgetary discipline and increase transparency.
Regarding the amendments to the Law on Corporate Income Tax, the Law on Non-Agricultural Land Use Tax, and the Law on Personal Income Tax, the Prime Minister said this is to institutionalize Resolutions 71 and 72 of the Politburo, which include the content of tax exemptions for businesses and individuals providing catering services to educational, medical, and healthcare facilities. "The corporate income tax revenue from these businesses is not a large figure, but the exemption has much greater significance, enhancing the quality of service for patients and students," the Prime Minister stated.
Regarding the tax rate for abandoned or unused land, or land for which use is delayed, the Prime Minister agreed with the opinions of the National Assembly delegates. The Government will direct the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development to continue to coordinate closely and review the regulations on abandoned and unused land to ensure they are clear, easy to apply, and feasible in practice; as well as to avoid tax overlaps and ensure consistency with the Land Law.
Regarding the Law on Bidding (amended), the Prime Minister raised the issue of distinguishing bidding activities carried out under the Law on Bidding and other relevant laws. This is the most difficult issue, especially in the fields of health, science and technology, and energy. Therefore, the draft Law clearly specifies: Normal bidding activities and those in specialized fields are to be implemented in accordance with specialized laws.
Along with that, empowering and raising the responsibility of project owners in deciding bidding and procurement activities ensures openness, transparency, and effectiveness. The draft also clarifies prohibited acts, authority to handle violations, and responsibilities of parties in bidding activities.
The Prime Minister stated that he will continue to direct a thorough review of regulations on ensuring competition and centralized procurement, especially in the health sector; as well as perfecting measures in emergency situations for the health of the people, including regulations on direct procurement for hospitals and medical facilities; as well as allowing direct procurement to reduce intermediaries and cut costs in some specific fields.
The Prime Minister emphasized that this Law must also provide measures to simplify procedures, create conditions for project owners to implement, but must also regulate very strictly; avoiding the phenomenon of "collusion", violations, and negativity of related parties.
On the other hand, the Prime Minister argued that because bid packages are very diverse in nature and type across industries and sectors, no single legal regulation can cover everything in practice. Therefore, the spirit is to strive to the highest degree to ensure the draft Law regulates the most crucial points in bidding; at the same time, there must be sub-law guidance documents for specific fields, with continuous research to make adjustments when issues arise. The goal is to achieve the highest efficiency in bidding, bring benefits to projects, and ensure cost control.
The Prime Minister noted the reality that through bidding, the saved budget is often very low, but direct contracting can immediately reduce the bid package price by 5 - 10% and be implemented very quickly and on schedule.
"Ultimately, the role of the project owner and investor is decisive; the final responsibility still lies with the people. If those organizing the implementation are not honest, objective, or acting in the general interest, bidding will still have violations, including in international bidding," the Prime Minister emphasized.
Therefore, the head of the Government believes that one must be flexible in practice and choose honest, serious officials who work for the general interest. At the same time, one of the key points of this draft Law is the post-audit mechanism based on final results. "Whether bidding or not, the final result is whether that contract package meets the requirements, both in terms of quality and economy," the Prime Minister clarified.
Ha Van
